Published November 18, 2026

What Do Buyers Ask First About a Home in Atlantic Highlands?

Author Avatar

Written by Melina Bradley

Melina Bradley, an Atlantic Highlands Realtor, in a green-walled hallway.

When we listed a home in Atlantic Highlands, the first three questions from buyers were about the town, not the house.

The short answer: Buyers asked how far it is to downtown, how far it is to the SeaStreak ferry, and how to get to Route 36. It's a good reminder of my number one rule: location over price.

1. How far to downtown?

Buyers wanted to know about the walk. Atlantic Highlands has a walkable First Avenue with places like Hudson Cafe, Nicholas Creamery and SModcastle Cinemas.

2. How far to the ferry?

SeaStreak runs ferries from Atlantic Highlands and Highlands to Manhattan. In my experience the ride is faster and more comfortable than the drive or the train. Check the current schedule, since it changes by season.

3. How do I get to Route 36?

Route 36 was the road buyers asked about. Ask for the drive from the exact address, at the time of day you'd actually go.

Why location comes first

You can renovate a kitchen. You can't move a house. Buyers tell us again and again that the neighborhood and how easily they can get around matter as much as the house itself.

If you're selling

Price your home for its location, and show buyers the Saturday: the walk, the ferry and the drive. Tell them what's close, and be specific.

Quick answers

Is Atlantic Highlands walkable to downtown? It depends on the street. Ask for the walk from the exact address.

Can you commute to New York from here? There's a ferry from Atlantic Highlands and Highlands, and train stations in nearby towns. Check each schedule.

What should I ask about flood zones? Check the address on FEMA's map and get an insurance quote. It's street by street.

Thinking about a move to Atlantic Highlands? Let's talk real estate. Call or text 609.469.4121 or 949.230.5508, or email melina@melinabradley.com. We live here. We work here. We serve here.

See our free home value or homes for sale.

About the author: Melina Bradley is an Atlantic Highlands resident, military spouse and award-winning Realtor with the Melina Bradley Real Estate Team at Keller Williams Realty West Monmouth. She has over $200 million in sales and over 350 clients served, across Monmouth, Middlesex and Ocean Counties, including Atlantic Highlands, Colts Neck, Hazlet, Highlands, Holmdel, Keyport, Manalapan, Marlboro, Middletown, Millstone, Old Bridge, Red Bank, Shrewsbury and Monroe.

Equal Housing Opportunity.

Sources: SeaStreak and Monmouth County Parks.

Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Melina Bradley

Operator | REALTOR® | Melina Bradley Real Estate Team | Keller Williams West Monmouth | PLACE

Agent profile image in message

or another way