Categories
About the AreaPublished November 7, 2026
What Are the Best Coffee Shops in Atlantic Highlands, NJ? Our Top 5 (Worth the Ferry From NYC)
What are the best coffee shops in Atlantic Highlands, NJ? These are our five favorites in this Monmouth County town, and yes, they are worth the ferry ride from New York City.
The short answer: Our favorites are Fair Mountain Coffee Roasters, Almost Home, Emilio's, Hudson Cafe and JÜS Organic. Each one has one order I'd go back for. These are my own picks, not a ranking, and I'd love to hear yours.
Atlantic Highlands sits on Sandy Hook Bay in Monmouth County, NJ, near Highlands, Middletown, Hazlet and Red Bank, so this makes an easy coffee day whether you live nearby or are coming in by ferry.
I live in Atlantic Highlands, and my day usually has a coffee in it. Here is where I go, and what I order.
1. Fair Mountain Coffee Roasters
What to order: the Jamaican Blue Mountain.
Fair Mountain is at 171 First Avenue. They roast organic, fair trade coffee, and they've been part of this town since 2012. If you love a cup you can really taste, start here. Ask what's pouring, since the Jamaican Blue Mountain is a special coffee.
2. Almost Home (at Red General)
What to order: the shaken espresso.
A shaken espresso is a double shot of espresso, vanilla and cinnamon, shaken over ice with your choice of milk. It's my afternoon pick-me-up.
3. Emilio's
What to order: the Latte Que Latte.
Emilio's is at 77 Center Avenue in Atlantic Highlands, and you may also know it as Zoe's Emilio's Kitchen. It's a breakfast and lunch restaurant with a menu that includes Mexican favorites, and the Latte Que Latte is a horchata and espresso drink. Take a look at their menu and hours before you go.
4. Hudson Cafe
What to order: the iced coffee.
Hudson Cafe is at 25 First Avenue. It's a breakfast, lunch and coffee spot, with baked goods. It's easy to grab an iced coffee and keep walking.
5. JÜS Organic
What to order: my Iced Maiden Brew, with protein, maple syrup and almond milk.
JÜS Organic is at 135 First Avenue. It's an all-organic spot that makes its own almond milk and uses Maiden cold brew coffee. My order is the iced Maiden brew with protein, maple syrup and almond milk. It's a coffee and a breakfast in one cup.
Why a coffee crawl in Atlantic Highlands works
Three of the five shops are on First Avenue, which is the heart of town. You can walk from one to the next, and then keep going to the marina, the Henry Hudson Trail, or the overlook at Mount Mitchill. If you take the ferry in from New York, it makes a great Saturday.
Quick answers
What are the best coffee shops in Atlantic Highlands? These five are our favorites: Fair Mountain Coffee Roasters, Almost Home, Emilio's, Hudson Cafe and JÜS Organic. Check each shop's hours before you go.
Can I take the ferry to Atlantic Highlands for coffee? Yes. SeaStreak runs ferries between Atlantic Highlands and Manhattan. Check the current schedule and fares.
What is a shaken espresso? A double shot of espresso with vanilla and cinnamon, shaken over ice with milk.
Thinking of living here? Many people ask me what life in Atlantic Highlands is like. This is part of it. Ask me for the town guide.
We live here. We work here. We serve here. Let's talk real estate. Call or text 609.469.4121 / 949.230.5508 or email melina@melinabradley.com.
About the author: I'm Melina Bradley, an Atlantic Highlands resident, a military spouse and an active, award-winning Realtor with the Melina Bradley Real Estate Team at Keller Williams Realty West Monmouth. We serve Monmouth, Middlesex and Ocean Counties, including Atlantic Highlands, Colts Neck, Hazlet, Highlands, Holmdel, Keyport, Manalapan, Marlboro, Middletown, Millstone, Old Bridge, Red Bank, Shrewsbury and Monroe.
See home search or a free home value. Also read Home for the Holidays: Free Community Movie Day in Atlantic Highlands on December 5.
Equal Housing Opportunity.
Melina Bradley
Operator | REALTOR® | Melina Bradley Real Estate Team | Keller Williams West Monmouth | PLACE
or another way