Published November 13, 2026

What Sellers in Monmouth County Need to Know Today

Author Avatar

Written by Melina Bradley

What Sellers in Monmouth County Need to Know Today header image.

Every week I hear it: "The market's softening." "Things are taking too long." "Let's wait."

The short answer: Home prices may seem like they are dropping. But when you look closely, the homes you like are the ones everyone is competing for. It is a market that asks more of sellers, and some homes sit a few more days. Properly priced homes, strategized for the season and measured against their real competition, are still winning in Monmouth County.

If you are thinking of selling, here is what matters today: how your home is priced, when you bring it to market and who it competes with.

What the September 2026 numbers show

One broker's report, which reads Redfin's county pages, listed these Monmouth County figures for September 2026:

Measure September 2026
Median sale price $733,858, up 1.2% from a year earlier
Days on market 25, unchanged
Listings with a price cut 17.3%, up 2.2 points
Sale price compared to list 100.7%
Sales above list price 45.2%

Price cuts rose. So did the share of listings cutting in every one of the state's 12 largest counties. But the median price rose a little, homes still sold in about 25 days, and the average home sold slightly above its list price. The report called it a pricing story, not a value story. County numbers are averages and can differ a lot from your town.

1. Which homes are dropping in price?

Are they homes you'd actually buy? In my experience, many price cuts are on homes that were priced too high to start. The homes you like, the ones that are priced right and show well, are the ones everyone is vying for.

2. Why did they drop?

Is it overpriced? Is it a house that isn't right for most buyers? Or a home that wasn't marketed with the right strategy? A cut on the wrong home tells you nothing about the homes you like.

3. Where did they really land?

Follow the homes you like and see where they sell. That's your market.

What sellers need to know right now

We are in a market that takes more care than it did, and some homes take a little longer. In my experience, three things still win:

  • Priced properly. The right price for the home, not the hopeful one.
  • Strategic for the season. Timing, photos and the launch plan should fit the time of year.
  • Looking at the competition. The homes buyers will compare yours to decide how it should be priced and presented.

Quick answers

Is the Monmouth County market crashing? The September numbers above don't show that. Ask us for your town's numbers.

Should I wait for lower prices? It depends on the homes you want. Buyers who have looked for a long time and know what they want are the ones moving quickly.

Should sellers cut the price? It depends on the home, the price and the strategy. Let's look at yours.

Let's talk real estate. Call or text 609.469.4121 or 949.230.5508, or email melina@melinabradley.com. We live here. We work here. We serve here.

See our free home value or homes for sale.

About the author: Melina Bradley is an Atlantic Highlands resident, military spouse and award-winning Realtor with the Melina Bradley Real Estate Team at Keller Williams Realty West Monmouth. She has over $200 million in sales and over 350 clients served, across Monmouth, Middlesex and Ocean Counties, including Atlantic Highlands, Colts Neck, Hazlet, Highlands, Holmdel, Keyport, Manalapan, Marlboro, Middletown, Millstone, Old Bridge, Red Bank, Shrewsbury and Monroe.

Equal Housing Opportunity.

Sources: Prodigy Real Estate, NJ housing market report, September 2026 data and Redfin, Monmouth County housing market.

Categories

Market News, Sellers
Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Melina Bradley

Operator | REALTOR® | Melina Bradley Real Estate Team | Keller Williams West Monmouth | PLACE

Agent profile image in message

or another way